Every hunter out there knows that it’s not all the same. You need different tools for specialized hunting and for different purposes, weapons and distances.
And seeing that deer hunting is such a popular sort of sport, with deer itself being a special quarry, it’s understandable why special equipment has been developed to meet the needs of deer hunters.
And that’s why we’re going to show you some of the best broadheads for deer we’ve found, to help you make more humane kills and reach your target with more precision. But first, let’s see how you can actually navigate the sea of broadheads and what factors influence your choice.
How to Get The Best
As always, getting the best of the best implies following some particular characteristics of the product and factor them in your decision-making process, depending on your purpose.
So nothing is set in stone, and we’re aware that every factor we’ll discuss has a different importance for everyone, but we think you should look at:
Materials and design
This is the utmost characteristic that should interest you when it comes to buying basically anything. If the materials are strong and sturdy and the construction is solid, then you’ve got yourself a tough broadhead.
The best materials used are:
- Stainless steel.
- Carbon steel alloy.
- 100% steel.
That’s because all of them are very strong and reliable on the field, and can’t be damaged very easily. The difference between them can be noticed in regards to the level of strength, weight, and price, although neither of them will cost you your life to buy.
For instance, aluminum is the least strong and least pricey of all, although it’s lightweight. If you’re looking for the lightest and strongest material available, that’s carbon steel, which is also the most expensive.
100% steel is the heaviest, and the most common choice is stainless steel which comes in the middle for all these categories.
Either way, make sure your broadhead is:
- Thick enough so that it doesn’t get damaged when hitting the deer.
- Compact enough so that it has minimal air friction.
- Easily sharpened.
- Easy to set up and take off.
- Strong and sharp.
That being said, don’t fall prey to a futuristic design that looks well but doesn’t get the job done. There are for example a lot of curved broadheads that take a lot of time to put them on, making you lose sight of your game. Not to mention sharpening them is hell.
There’s also somewhat of an argument between replaceable pedals and one-piece broadheads. The first cost less and give you the option of quickly changing the blades if you don’t like re-sharpening your broadhead. On the other hand, they’re not as sharp and don’t have the same precision and penetration ability as one-piece broadheads.
The cutting diameter differs depending on the size of the game you’re after. So for deer, you’ll need a bigger cutting diameter than for a smaller quarry, but you’ll also have to follow the legal requirements of your state. Basically:
- Bigger cutting diameters make a bigger wound but have less penetration force.
- Smaller cutting diameters leave a smaller insert wound but have more penetration force.
That’s easily explained through air friction: a bigger cutting diameter will have more wind resistance, therefore less speed and less force.
You can also look for expandable broadheads, which are amazing for dealing with this issue.
So they can provide a small enough cutting diameter for more speed and increased penetration force, and then open up to produce a bigger wound inside. That’s what will help you make a fast, merciful kill. Which leads us to the following argument regarding:
We always love a good friendly dispute, as it usually happens with regards to hunting equipment.
But it’s up to you to choose between fixed and mechanical broadheads.
Fine-tuning them right from the start on your bow is a pain because they behave like a miniature helm when the arrow flies. So practically the bow itself has to be stabilized to precision, or otherwise, your arrow will fly off its course. That’s why the cutting diameter of this sort of blade is pretty small.
But the advantage is they’re fixed, which means they’re resistant and can easily get through bone since their smaller cutting diameter will give them more force on impact.
Although these have a bigger diameter, they’re simpler to shoot and you don’t have to minutely tune your bow beforehand. The fact that they can expand has a lot of advantages, but we’ve already mentioned them above. They also leave a huge blood trail for easier tracking, but the problem is they don’t really do that well when hitting a bone.
The tip of your broadhead should be taken into account too, since there two main tips:
- Chisel-like, which is stronger.
- Cut on contact, which is sharper.
So you should make sure the tip complements the cutting diameter and the sort of blade your broadhead has. Stronger is better for a smaller diameter and a fixed blade system, while sharper rounds up the characteristics of a bigger cutting diameter and a mechanical blade broadhead.
The Broadheads That Would Make Odin Proud
Taking all that into account, let’s see what the market has in store for you. It’s important to choose a trustworthy brand because they manufacture reliable products, which can easily be researched online.
Plus, they won’t cost and arm and a leg either, they’ll last longer and some of them even have good warranties.
Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead
Weight: 3.2 ounces
Dimensions: 2 x 2.5 x 2 inches
Specifications: 0.035 inches stainless steel blades; 2 inches cutting diameter; one-piece; practice head included; Shock Collar technology
Best Use: deer hunting
Description: This 4.3 stars and $35.97 Rage Hypodermic Standard Broadhead is a mechanical broadhead, manufactured from stainless steel. This material ensures you of its great quality since it’s strong enough, yet pretty light to be confidently used when hunting with a crossbow.
Apart from the good weight and dimensions, the precision of this particular item is further ensured by the brand’s reputation. As such, you can be sure it’s very accurate, making deep wound channels so that the deer you shoot don’t have to suffer needlessly.
The hybrid tip it has is another thing that provides surgical-like precision, which is thanks to the exclusive technology used by Rage.
And if you still don’t feel really in control of your shooting, you can easily get more practice with the included practice head that comes with this product. That way, you’ll be sure to hit your target every time.
The accuracy you need is given by the aerodynamic form of this broadhead and the fact that its ferrule is made from steel but in just one piece. That aspect is what makes it really tough seeing as one-piece items have fewer chances of dismembering on the field. The broadhead has very sharp blades, manufactured from 0.35-inch stainless steel, with a 2-inch cutting diameter and a 100-grain broadhead.
Moreover, the fact that it’s refined with the Shock Collar technology makes all the difference in the world in regards to blade retention. The rear blade deployment is another great feature, as is the fact that it’s compatible with the Deep Six insert.
Rage Chisel Three Blade Broadhead
Weight: 2.4 ounces
Dimensions: 10.8 x 6.1 x 1.9 inches
Specifications: chisel tip; 0.35 inches stainless steel blades; 1.5 inches cutting diameter; 100 grains broadhead; Shock Collar technology; blade retention; included practice head
Best Use: deer hunting
Description: This 4.2 stars and $33.82 Rage Chisel Three Blade Broadhead is another awesome mechanical broadhead courtesy of Rage. That’s because Rage is known for their design care, and the accuracy of their broadheads is renowned.
This particular broadhead is another one that’s perfect for hunting deer since it ensures an easy and deep penetration. That means the animal’s suffering is minimized, but also that you can easily extract the arrow from the deep wound channels.
The tip has a chiseled design, which renders it very powerful: like a chisel breaking stone or metal, this broadhead can inflict the same damage on bones. That means it’s tough enough not to be broken or stopped by a bone, always reaching its target and killing the quarry.
The materials from which this broadhead is manufactured also ensure this happens. For instance, the blades are very sharp and strong, since they’re made from 0.035-inch stainless steel, and have a 1.5-inch cutting diameter.
The broadhead itself is 100-grain, so that’s pretty good too, although not as great as the red anodized ferrules used for its increased sturdiness.
But the exclusive Shock Collar technology is yet another plus since blade retention is guaranteed. In fact, the whole ShockLock system used for ensuring blade retention is particular to the broadheads with chisel tips retailed by Rage.
You’ll easily recognize these sort of broadheads since they have special chisel points, which are black and coated with nickel, making them resistant to friction.
And if you want to squeeze in some more practice before starting off in your hunting adventure, this broadhead comes with its included practice head too.
Muzzy Broadheads New Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3 Blade
Weight: 2.9 ounces
Dimensions: 2 x 1.2 x 1.6 inches
Specifications: 100-grain; 3 blades; 0.035-inch blades; right-helix design; 1.2-inch cutting diameter; one-piece
Best Use: deer hunting
Description: This 4.3 stars and $23.73 Muzzy Broadheads New Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3 Blade has a strong and precise design since it’s manufactured from three blades. That makes it perfect for deep penetration, as well as the instant killing off your target; after all, it is a 100-grain broadhead.
The blades themselves are very sturdy and strong since they’re made from 0.035-inch stainless steel, a renowned material for its ability to withstand damages while being fairly light at the same time.
In fact, the low total weight of this broadhead renders it perfect to be used when crossbow hunting, so you can be sure your arrow flies as it should, hitting its target very accurately.
Its precision is further ensured by the construction of this broadhead since it has a right helix design that will help your arrow stay very stable and on the proper course. The accuracy of this broadhead is especially noticeable when you’re hunting at longer ranges.
The cutting diameter provided by the Muzzy Trocar is fairly big, reaching about 1.2 inches. Although it’s not the biggest one on the market, it still does a wonderful job when it comes to penetrating the flesh of bigger game like deer and elk.
But the fact that its ferrule is made from one piece steel is what really explains its ability to kill bigger animals since it’s less likely to get damaged when cutting through their flesh. It’s also what makes it less likely to break if you accidentally hit a bone.
G5 Outdoors Montec CS Broadhead
Weight: 1.6 ounces
Dimensions: 2 x 1.6 x 1.6 inches
Specifications: 100-grain; 3 steel blades; 3 pack; 1.2 inches cutting diameter; metal injection molding; can be re-sharpened
Best Use: deer hunting
Description: This 4.6 stars and $44.95 G5 Outdoors Montec CS Broadhead is a very advantageous buy because for this price you’ll actually get three fixed broadheads, all weighing in at 100 grains, which is truly an awesome deal.
That means you’ll be able to replace them on the field as you need too, without having to re-sharpen them.
Which in fact, is another option you have with the Montec CS and that’s a real positive because it allows you multiple uses.
The cutting diameter is 1.2 inches, making it enough to penetrate the skin and muscle of larger animals like deer, and accurately killing them without excessive suffering.
The three blades used for the construction of this broadhead explain its overall strength and its ability to make a merciful killing since it surgically stabs the prey. In fact, it’s said that this Montec CS is 25% sharper than the initial product.
Besides, the blades are made with a patented design, with metal injection molding that gives it more strength. You can easily use this broadhead even with a compound bow that’s not very fast, and you’ll mortally wound the deer, even if you hit a bone in the process.
You’ll see it run for a few yards and then drop fast, making your tracking very easy. At about $13 per broadhead, this is amazing considering they come very sharp and tough.
That’s explainable thanks to their carbon steel construction, which makes them really sharp and resistant, even more so than the ones made from stainless steel.
Besides, you’ll be amazed at their consistency, because each of the three included broadheads weighs 100 grains. That means you can use them at distances as big as 60 yards, which is pretty nice, giving you the option of following the blood trail to catch the deer.
G5 Outdoors T3 Crossbow Broadhead
Weight: 1.8 ounces
Dimensions: 1.5 x 6.5 x 10.5 inches
Specifications: expandable blades; all steel; 1.5 inches cutting diameter; 100-grain; Spider Clip system; practice and replacement blades included
Best Use: deer hunting
Description: This 4.2 stars and $39.76 mechanical G5 Outdoors T3 Crossbow Broadhead is amazing when it comes to maximizing the cutting area since it’s made with three expandable blades. That means the air friction until getting to the target is reduced, thus gaining more speed and force.
Although the penetration hole can be quite small, the penetrating force itself is big and the blades will expand very deep inside, making for a fast, humane kill.
The construction is very sturdy since the whole broadhead is made from steel, which is one of the best materials for increased strength. The 100 grains weight is pretty good when it comes to using this broadhead with crossbows of different draw weights and also at bigger distances.
That’s an advantage because you can’t easily approach deer in an open field without them spotting you first.
The cutting diameter is 1.5 inches, which is pretty good for making your kill, and you should know that there is no blade pre-deployment though they’re expandable.
That adds to the penetration force, as does the field tip profile you’ll find in the closed position. The blade retention system itself is an advanced one, using Spider Clips, and the good news is you have some replacement ones available.
Other included extras are the replacement and the practice blades. So you don’t need to think about re-sharpening your broadhead on the field, you can simply replace it with the available inserts.
And if you need some target practice before going on your first hunting trip, you’ll get the chance with the three included practice blades that are very similar to the ones used for the field.
Wasp Jak Hammer SST Select-A-Cut 100GR
Weight: 0.2 ounces
Dimensions: 2.3 x 1.8 x 0.5 inches
Specifications: adjustable diameter; stainless steel tip; 0.027-inch blades; 100 grains broadhead; neoprene O-ring
Best Use: deer hunting
Description: This 4.5 stars and $43.63 Wasp Jak Hammer SST Select-A-Cut 100GR is really groundbreaking technologically speaking, seeing as you can adjust its cutting diameter fairly easy.
All you have to do is rotate its washer and you can get from a 1.5-inch diameter to a 1.75-inch diameter, allowing you to make the right choice depending on the situation you’re in: if you have to shoot a bigger deer and from afar, you’ll have to select the bigger option as that makes a larger entry wound.
The trocar-like tip is made with three-sided cutting points thanks to its three included blades. The fact that this tip is manufactured with stainless steel increases the penetration force, making it easy for the broadhead to even get through bones.
That’s also explained by the fact that the tip is precision machined and hardened to Rockwell 46C.
The blades themselves are razor sharp right out of the box because they are well grounded and refined, so that they match the tip’s edges perfectly, and make the penetrating wound bigger. They’re 0.027 inches, which really lets you see how sharp they are.
The 100 grains weight of this broadhead explains its strength and precision, helping you hit your target even from longer distances.
The O-ring is made from neoprene, which ensures that it won’t stretch with time and that it’s resistant to rotting. Its round shape is obtained mechanically, and it’s more performant than the rubber bands generally used for this purpose.
That’s what will help the blades be released together at once when the O-ring is deployed. That basically gives you huge wounds, that makes tracking easier because you can follow the prominent blood trail to your quarry.
The Broadhead You Favor
We’ve reviewed some of the best items on the market in the category of broadheads, and hopefully, that’s given you an idea on what to look for when it comes to broadheads that are most suited for hunting deer.
Now that’s been said, let us know which sort of product you like more and why. Which broadhead would you buy? Is there a specific brand you like more? And with the risk of adding more fuel to the fire, what sort of broadhead do you think is better: a fixed or a mechanical one?
We really value your input, so don’t be shy, the comment section is right below!